Skip to main content

Best Ball Positional Scarcity: Which Positions to Target Early in Best Ball Drafts

Positional scarcity is the idea that as you move down the draft board, the quality drop-off from one player to the next at some positions is steeper than others. The positions with steep drop-offs early in the draft are the ones you cannot afford to wait on.

Best Ball Scarcity Quick Reference

Position Scarcity level When quality runs out Best ball draft priority
Running back Highest — true workhorse RBs are rare Rounds 4–5: fewer than 15 true workhorses; committee backs dominate after that Address early OR commit to zero-RB and accumulate volume in rounds 5–10
Tight end (top-5) Very high — elite TE tier is dramatically better than TE10+ Rounds 2–4: if you miss the top 5, you are in budget TE territory Take elite TE in rounds 2–4 if available; punt if you miss the tier entirely
Wide receiver (top tier) Moderate — WR is deep but elite WRs are real Rounds 1–5: WR1-WR15 meaningfully better than WR25+; depth exists but drops off Target early-round WRs for upside; fill with volume WRs in rounds 6–10
Quarterback (1QB league) Low — 32 NFL starters, only 12 needed in a 12-team league Rounds 8–12: waiting is fine; only streamers are a problem (can’t stream in best ball) Draft a consistent starter, not a streamer — do not take the last in a QB run
Quarterback (2QB/superflex) Very high — same as dynasty superflex scarcity logic Rounds 1–4: take 2 QBs by round 4 or accept a below-average QB2 all season Never apply 1QB draft logic to a 2QB league — the position changes entirely
Defense/ST and Kicker Not applicable — do not draft these positions in best ball N/A Skip DST and K in best ball; every roster spot is more valuable as a WR, RB, QB, or TE

How Scarcity Works in Best Ball

No waivers = scarcity is permanent. In redraft, a thin position at draft can be addressed through the waiver wire during the season. Missed on an RB early? Add an injury replacement or breakout player in Week 3. In best ball, your draft roster is your entire roster. Failing to address a scarce position at draft means living with that hole all season.

The auto-lineup compounds scarcity. Best ball auto-sets the optimal lineup each week. If you have depth at WR and thin at RB, the auto-lineup maximizes your WR scoring. But if your thin RB position never generates upside weeks, your overall score underperforms regardless of your WR depth.

Position Scarcity Tiers in Best Ball

Running back (highest scarcity). RB is the most scarce position in best ball drafts. There are roughly 32 potential RB1 situations in the NFL at any given time, but fewer than 15 are true volume-based workhorse starters. The rest are committee backs, receiving specialists, or injury backups.

By Round 4–5 of any 12-team best ball draft, the quality RBs who can sustain double-digit fantasy points consistently are gone. Managers who wait on RBs past Round 5–6 are typically piecing together committees — which can work in best ball due to auto-lineup optimization, but requires drafting 6–7 RBs to compensate.

Wide receiver (moderate scarcity). WR scarcity is real but more forgiving. There are 64 potential WR1/WR2 situations in the NFL (two per team) plus strong WR3 slot options. The position has more depth than RB.

However, the best WRs — those who produce 120-plus receiving yards multiple times per season — are legitimately scarce. The WR1–WR15 tier in any draft is meaningfully better than WR25–WR35.

Quarterback (lower scarcity in 1QB leagues). In standard 1QB leagues, QB is the least scarce position because only one manager in each league starts a QB at the same time — and there are 32 starting QBs in the NFL. Waiting on QB in 1QB best ball is generally correct. The exception is streaming-tier QBs who only produce against favorable matchups — those are not best ball friendly since you cannot stream in best ball.

Tight end (high scarcity at top tier). The top 3–5 TEs in fantasy are dramatically better than TE10–TE20. In best ball, if you miss the top TE tier, you are typically starting a TE whose floor is minimal most weeks. The TE scarcity question is binary: do you get a top-5 TE or do you punt the position?

Practical Draft Priority

  1. Top RBs first when available in Rounds 1–2
  2. Premium WRs alongside or instead of RBs in Rounds 1–4
  3. Top TE in Rounds 1–4 if available at reasonable ADP discount
  4. QB last in standard 1QB (early in 2QB/superflex)
  5. RB depth in Rounds 5–10 to compensate for scarcity

For how scarcity interacts with stack strategy in best ball, see: Best Ball Stack Strategy: How to Use QB-WR Stacks to Maximize Your Best Ball Ceiling.