Skip to main content

Best Ball ADP Strategy: How to Buy Value and Avoid Overpaying at Your Draft

Average Draft Position (ADP) is one of the most valuable tools in best ball — and one of the most misused. Understanding what ADP actually measures, where it comes from, and how to exploit it gives you an edge before a single pick is made.

What ADP Is (and What It Isn’t)

ADP is the average pick number at which a specific player has been drafted across a sample of best ball leagues on a given platform. An ADP of 24.3 means this player has been going, on average, with the 24th pick overall.

What ADP measures: The market’s current consensus on a player’s value.

What ADP doesn’t measure:

  • Whether the consensus is correct
  • Forward-looking information (injury, depth chart change) that hasn’t been priced in yet
  • Your league’s specific context (format, scoring, roster size)
  • The specific pool of people you’re drafting against (casual vs. shark-heavy tournament)

ADP is a snapshot of what the average market participant thinks. Your job is to be better-informed than the average market participant in specific spots.

How to Read ADP Data

Positional ADP (relative rank): More useful than raw pick numbers. Knowing a WR is “WR22” tells you where he ranks among WRs, regardless of overall pick position. This lets you spot where positional scarcity creates value.

ADP movement: An ADP trending downward (from 4.2 to 6.8 over 2 weeks) signals the market is adjusting against this player — perhaps due to injury news, depth chart change, or the field catching up to something. ADP trending upward means the market is pricing someone higher as more information favors him.

ADP by platform: Underdog ADP differs from ESPN/Yahoo ADP. The player pool and scoring format differ, so compare platform-specific ADP to your target platform. Using Underdog ADP for an Underdog best ball draft is more relevant than using Yahoo’s general ADP.

Time period: ADP in June reflects a much less informed market than ADP in mid-July after training camp reports have shaped the field. Early-season ADP misprices more players — opportunity and risk both increase.

The Core ADP Strategy: Buy Value, Avoid Overpay

Buy value: Find players you believe will produce more than their ADP suggests. Take them at their ADP (not a round earlier).

Avoid overpay: If a player’s ADP is already high because the field loves him, you need to be even more confident in him to justify taking him at that price. If you’re not more confident than the market, you’re essentially neutral on the pick.

The mistake: Drafting on “reputation” rather than current ADP. A manager who always takes Patrick Mahomes in Round 1 because “he’s the best QB” is not analyzing ADP — he’s anchored to prior seasons. If Mahomes is ADP 8 but your analysis says he’s a Round 3 value in 1QB, taking him Round 1 means you overpaid by two rounds.

Types of ADP Mispricing

1. Recent News Not Yet Priced In

ADP updates every few days on most platforms. A player who gets a depth chart upgrade (starter goes on PUP, team cuts the incumbent) on Monday may still have his pre-news ADP on Tuesday. By Wednesday the market has moved. By next Monday, the new ADP reflects the change.

Exploit window: 12–72 hours after meaningful news breaks.

How to act: Check beat reporter updates and real-time depth chart news daily. When you see a meaningful update that hasn’t moved ADP yet, act on it in your next draft.

2. Recency Bias in Both Directions

Upward recency bias: A player who had a massive career year last season has inflated ADP because the field is anchoring to peak output. If last year’s output was due to a situation (great OC, weak schedule) that has changed, his ADP overstates his forward value.

Downward recency bias: A player who had an injury-shortened season or a down year is priced on last year’s output even if the underlying situation is unchanged (or better). His ADP understates forward value.

Both directions create opportunity. Sell the players anchored to their career highs into inflated ADP; buy the players whose ADP has been dragged down by temporary factors.

3. Scheme Changes That Haven’t Been Priced

A new offensive coordinator can significantly change a player’s value — both up and down. The field is slow to update ADP for scheme changes because:

  • Most managers don’t follow OC hiring closely
  • The impact takes a few weeks of training camp reporting to confirm
  • The field prices the previous OC’s system into the current year

How to exploit: Follow OC/HC hiring news closely in the offseason. Identify which players benefit from the new system (Air Raid benefits slot receivers; West Coast benefits pass-catching backs; etc.) and which players lose. Act on ADP that hasn’t adjusted yet.

4. Market Exposure Effect

Players on high-profile teams (Cowboys, Patriots historically, Chiefs, 49ers currently) often have inflated ADP because more casual managers watch those teams and anchor their valuations to perceived team quality.

The reality: A WR on a mid-market team in a strong passing offense may outproduce a WR on a marquee team with worse quarterback play. ADP doesn’t always correct for this.

How to exploit: Specifically look for high-volume offenses on non-marquee teams. Their pass-catchers are often slightly undervalued relative to equivalent volume players on high-profile teams.

Building Your ADP-Based Draft Sheet

Before every best ball draft, run through this prep:

Step 1: Pull the current ADP for your platform Use real-time ADP from the platform you’re drafting on. Underdog for Underdog, Yahoo for Yahoo, etc.

Step 2: Mark players you think are overvalued (red flag) These are players you’ll pass on at their ADP but might take a round or two later if they fall.

Step 3: Mark players you think are undervalued (green flag) These are players you’re willing to take at their ADP or even one round earlier if the draft requires it.

Step 4: Identify your “reach” threshold For any player you’re willing to take early, know exactly how early. If you’d take WR X at pick 40 but his ADP is 55, your reach limit is pick 40. If he hasn’t been taken at pick 50, you take him. Don’t reach beyond your limit.

Step 5: Build a stack plan Before the draft, identify 3 QB-WR stacks you’d build your entry around. Know which QB and which receiver you’d pair. Have 2 backup stacks ready if your first choice is gone.

ADP as a Dynamic Tool

ADP changes throughout the draft season (June–August for NFL). Your analysis should update with it:

  • Early June: Lots of uncertainty, ADP has wide error bars
  • Late June: OTA reports start shaping market
  • July: Training camp opens, injury reports start, ADP becomes more reliable
  • August: Preseason games, depth charts clarify, ADP stabilizes before final adjustments
  • Week of the NFL opener: ADP is most current — all available information is priced in

The best best-ball drafters are actively updating their ADP-based analysis in real time throughout the summer rather than locking in a static set of opinions in May and not revisiting.

For more on draft construction, see: Best Ball Draft Strategy and Stacking Strategy Guide.